No one has ever accused Tom Fazio of being a minimalist.
In fact he himself seems almost hostile to the idea that there’s virtue to building holes with as little construction involved as possible. Why not take full control of the design process if that’s an option? If Donald Ross, A.W. Tillinghast, et. al. had modern industrial machines, he’s written, they’d surely have used them.
To my knowledge he hasn’t worked on many properties where it isn’t necessary to more or less engineer a course, so his outlook is understandable. It would be fascinating to see what he’d do with a site like Bandon, Barnbougle or the Sand Hills (then again, I’d rather see some other fresh-perspective architect get a shot on the next great property). He did do pretty good at World Woods, another wonderful, sandy site.
That’s not to say he doesn’t believe in blending holes into the environment and making them look like extensions of the land. In fact he’s very good at it. One of his highest achievements in matching design with a sense of place is Sea Island’s Seaside course in southeast Georgia.
The resort hired Fazio in the late-’90’s to combine two of the property’s four nine-hole courses — Seaside, built by Henry Colt and Charles Alison in the mid-1920’s (renovated by Robert Trent Jones in 1949), and Marshside, a 1973 Joe Lee addition — into a coherent 18 (Rees Jones did the same with the Plantation and Retreat nines).
Fazio cleared out trees and introduced an open air, linksy theme to unify the holes. Though the course is actually located on the western Intracoastal side of St. Simons Island the dunescapes of seagrass and scrub oak, which increase in volume the closer the play gets to the shoreline, feel indigenous. It’s not oceanfront, but it’s the essence of coastal.
The first nine (the old Marshside routing) moves out toward toward the salt water marshes surrounding King Creek with two standout holes — the exposed 4th and 5th, back-to-back par-4’s that dogleg sharply in opposite directions around the everglades — though the short par-4 8th, with a an elevated green tucked to the right behind a pair of flashed brow bunkers, gives them a run.
One of the best nine-hole runs in Georgia begins with 10 and 11, par-4’s that dash between sandy dunes toward the sound.
The par-4 13th, running out again toward the marshes, sets up with a drive across a tidal marsh to a fairway slanting diagonally right to left. You choose how much to bite off — safe lines to the right may run through the fairway into bunkers, and hero plays along the hazard farther up the left get a straight-in shot to a green sitting up in the winds atop a rounded dune.
Conceptually it’s similar to the Raynor/Macdonald “Leven” hole, but the particular elements and aesthetics here are deserving of their own template recognition. The “Seaside” hole, perhaps?
This set-up is revisited on the 16th hole, another par-4 playing across a canal, although the orientation here is such that only the biggest of hitters can make the 270+ yard carry to really open up the shallow green.
Exposed greens drifting off into close-cut surrounds work well with the coastal winds — they can be difficult to hit and hold but aren’t punishing on misses. A majority — notably the 1st, 3rd, 7th, 10th and 11th — are pushed up and crowned in the mode of Pinehurst No. 2, while others, like the 4th, 9th and 14th, are set into the grade of the fairway, bleeding into the surrounding formations.
Fazio mentioned to me once that Seaside was one of his favorite projects. It’s easy to see why — Sea Island is an historic property with golf full of existing character, the setting is sensational and he was able to execute an attractive, comprehensive theme.
A few of the holes don’t quite contribute, like the 2nd with a green set against an interior lake, and the 17th and 18th that lack the kind of defining shots or features you desire coming in. But the atmosphere of the course and the way it harmonizes with the environment (even if it is created) is pitch perfect, and holes are at home in their habitat. It’s not minimalism, but it achieves what minimalism proposes, which is to present golf that meshes with the best features of a property. (94)
St. Simons Island
Architects: Henry Colt & Charles Alison; Robert Trent Jones (1949); Joe Lee; Tom Fazio (1999)