Another Storied Course Closes - Texas' Pecan Valley
The 9th at Pecan Valley.
For the fifth consecutive year, American golf course closures outnumbered new course openings. The courses are not necessarily the unheralded nondescript ones closing either. San Antonio's Pecan Valley is the latest relatively famous course to close. Built in 1963 by Press Maxwell, the course has been long considered an excellent public course and underwent considerable renovations in 1998. In fact, Pecan Valley is the first major championship site to close in the United States since Pomonok Country Club in Queens, New York, site of the 1939 PGA Championship, was sold in 1949.
It surprised people when Pecan Valley was chosen in 1968 to host the PGA Championship. Whether it was of major championship caliber is debatable, but it was certainly a better than average course with some of the oldest trees in Texas on the property that defined the challenge making it a shot-maker's course. It was no wonder when two excellent ball-strikers contended there. Julius Boros edged out Arnold Palmer in a thrilling finish to win and become the oldest major championship winner at the age of 48. Palmer was always known for his heroics and a plaque marks the spot on the 18th hole where Palmer hit a screaming 3-wood onto the long par-four green only to miss a 12 foot putt. Moments later, Boros responded wedging close enough to secure a par and the victory.
Pecan Valley also hosted the 1967 , 1969, and 1970 Texas Opens in addition to the USGA's Public Links Championship in 2001.
According to documents, no plans for redevelopment have been submitted for the property, but the layout is a popular one and it is hoped that someone may take over control and re-open it at some point.
There is local support to reopen the layout. A local stockbroker Chip Puhl, a former golf pro and USGA volunteer, is spearheading a plan to purchase the course and turn it over to the city as a municipal layout. He plans to follow the foundation model, which helped save East Lake Golf Club in Atlanta.
We're in this fight until the very end, until we win this battle or there is nothing left to fight for, Puhl said. Puhl plans to create a new organization called the San Antonio Municipal Golf Foundation to raise money to purchase the course and turn it over to the city. Puhl said he hoped to raise $2.5 million and already has pledges from some wealthy local citizens. The problem is that the golf course owner may not be a willing seller. They may get more money for the property by converting it to housing.
Pecan Valley's owner is Foresight Golf Management which also operates a successful and highly acclaimed public course just three miles away, The Republic, which it has actively marketed as a replacement for Pecan Valley. In talking points passed out to Pecan Valley employees last week, Foresight said closing Pecan Valley was not an easy decision but the course was too difficult for the average golfer and was not financially viable.
Ed Miller, CEO of Foresight, said he doubted the course would reopen under new management. I talked to a few people about it, but mainly I've tried to talk them out of it, Miller said. We probably wouldn't rule out any alternative, but I don't think golf is the best alternative for that property. Miller confirmed previous reports that Foresight had gone to the city last fall with a proposal for multi-family housing and a nine-hole course at Pecan Valley. Is golf the best and highest use of the Pecan Valley property? Time will tell, but for now there is no more golf at Pecan Valley.